Fix and Furrow
Advertise

Part of our Roofing and Exterior guide

Roof Underlayment for Asphalt Shingles: Felt vs Synthetic

Where code and shingle makers say you can't skip it, where ice and water shield pays off, and what a fair per-square quote looks like.

Save to Pinterest

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never changes what we recommend. Learn more

Roof deck covered with synthetic underlayment, with asphalt shingles being laid along the eave
Photo: Zohair Mirza on Unsplash

The short answer

For a standard re-roof in a mixed climate, buy synthetic underlayment over the full deck and add self-adhered ice and water shield only at eaves, valleys, penetrations, and low-slope sections. Synthetic typically adds roughly $10 to $30 per square over felt, or a few hundred dollars on a 25-square roof, and it handles weather delays and foot traffic better.

Typical cost
$20 to $70 per square installed for felt or synthetic; $120 to $250 per square for self-adhered
Time needed
Underlayment typically adds half a day to a day on a re-roof
Skill level
Hire a pro

Key points

  • Synthetic underlayment over the whole deck is the best-value choice for most asphalt shingle re-roofs, mainly because it tolerates exposure and tears less.
  • Ice and water shield belongs at eaves in cold climates, in valleys, around penetrations, and on low slopes, not usually across the entire roof.
  • Slip resistance, exposure time, and tear strength matter; color, brand slogans, and thickness labels alone don't.
  • Local code and your shingle manufacturer's instructions set the minimums, so check both before you accept a quote.
  • A fair quote names the underlayment product, shows where self-adhered membrane goes, and prices bad decking separately.
In this guide
  1. What does roof underlayment actually do?
  2. What are the main types of underlayment?
  3. Which features matter when you buy?
  4. Which features don't matter much?
  5. Where is ice and water shield worth the money?
  6. What does underlayment cost, and what should a quote include?
  7. What's the best choice for the most common situation?

Buy synthetic underlayment for the full roof deck, then add strips of self-adhered membrane where water actually gets in. That's the short answer for most re-roofs on a standard pitched roof in a mixed climate. Here's which pieces you can't skip and how to read a contractor's quote line by line.

What does roof underlayment actually do?

Roof underlayment is a secondary water barrier between the roof deck and the shingles, there to shed whatever water gets past the shingles. Wind-driven rain, ice dams, and nail holes mean some moisture always reaches that layer. It also protects the bare deck while the crew works.

It won't rescue rotted plywood. It doesn't replace flashing, drip edge, or attic ventilation, and it isn't a finished roof you can leave exposed for months. Every product has an exposure limit printed on the roll.

What are the main types of underlayment?

The three main types are asphalt-saturated felt, synthetic sheets, and self-adhered (peel-and-stick) membranes. Each does a different job, and most good roofs use more than one.

TypeWhat it isStrengthsWeak spotsBest use
15 lb feltThin asphalt-saturated paperCheapest, code-recognized in many areasWrinkles when wet, tears easily, short exposure windowDry climates, quick installs, tight budgets
30 lb feltHeavier saturated paperTougher than 15 lb, familiar to every crewStill absorbs moisture, heavy rolls, can buckleBudget option on simple roofs
Synthetic underlaymentWoven or spun polymer sheet, often texturedStrong, light, longer exposure, lays flatCosts more; quality varies widely by productFull-deck coverage on most re-roofs
Self-adhered underlaymentRubberized asphalt membrane with a sticky backSeals around nails, waterproof at problem spotsPriciest, impermeable, needs a clean dry deckEaves, valleys, penetrations, low slopes

The 15 lb and 30 lb names are legacy designations, and actual roll weights vary by product. Still, 30 lb felt is the sturdier of the two. It resists tearing and wrinkling better, which gives the shingles a flatter base. If you go with felt, we'd pick 30 lb and skip the thinner stuff on a re-roof.

Which features matter when you buy?

Slip resistance, exposure time, and tear strength matter most, along with how the sheet behaves when wet. Those decide whether the roof stays dry during installation and for years after.

  • Slip resistance. Textured synthetics generally grip better than felt, but any underlayment turns slick with dew, frost, or dust.
  • UV exposure time. Felt is usually meant to be covered within days to a few weeks. Synthetics are often rated for a month or more, sometimes several. Read the roll, because shingles don't always go on on schedule, especially in a rainy fall.
  • Tear strength and fastener hold. Wind catches loose underlayment before shingles go on. A sheet that resists tearing around cap nails stays put.
  • Behavior when wet. Felt absorbs water and ripples, which can telegraph through the shingles. Synthetic lies flat.
  • Standards compliance. Look for the ASTM standard or an ICC-ES evaluation report on the packaging. The International Code Council publishes the model codes most local rules are built on.

Which features don't matter much?

Color, brand slogans, and a thickness number on their own tell you little about how a product will perform on your roof. Don't pay extra for any of them without something firmer behind it.

Color mostly affects how hot the surface feels underfoot. Thickness in mils says nothing about strength by itself. "Waterproof" is a marketing word too: laps and fastener holes mean ordinary underlayment is water-resistant, not a sealed membrane. Ask for tear strength, exposure rating, and the standard it meets instead.

One thing outranks all of this: your shingle manufacturer's installation instructions. Some warranties, especially enhanced ones, require particular underlayment or ice barrier details. A roofer who follows National Roofing Contractors Association guidance should know this, but get it in writing.

Where is ice and water shield worth the money?

Ice and water shield pays off at eaves in cold climates, in valleys, around penetrations, and on low-slope sections, and rarely across the entire roof. Those are the places where water backs up, pools, or pours in concentrated flow.

  • Eaves. Where ice dams are a risk, model code typically calls for an ice barrier from the eave edge to at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall line, measured horizontally. With a 12-inch overhang and a 6:12 pitch, that usually means two courses of a 36-inch roll.
  • Valleys. A strip centered in the valley, commonly 36 inches wide, is standard practice and often a manufacturer requirement.
  • Penetrations and walls. Chimneys, skylights, plumbing vents, and sidewall junctions leak more than any open field of shingles.
  • Low slopes. Sections from 2:12 to under 4:12 usually need double underlayment or a self-adhered layer under code and shingle instructions. Below 2:12, standard asphalt shingles generally aren't approved at all.

In freezing climates you almost certainly want it at the eaves. In mild ones, valleys and penetrations still earn it. Your local building department can tell you what's required where you live, since this varies by jurisdiction, and whether your re-roof needs a permit. Many do.

Covering the whole deck with self-adhered underlayment costs several times more and can slow drying of the roof deck, so it only makes sense for very low slopes or a specific design call.

What does underlayment cost, and what should a quote include?

Typical U.S. pricing runs roughly $20 to $70 per square installed for felt or synthetic and $120 to $250 per square for self-adhered, where a square is 100 square feet. Labor, roof height and pitch, and regional demand move those numbers.

TypeInstalled per square (typical range)
15 lb felt$20 to $40
30 lb felt$30 to $55
Synthetic underlayment$40 to $70
Self-adhered underlayment$120 to $250

On a 25-square roof, synthetic over the whole deck typically adds a few hundred dollars over felt. Self-adhered strips at eaves and valleys can add several hundred more, depending on eave length, valley count, and penetrations. Both are modest next to the total roof price.

A fair quote spells out:

  • The underlayment type and product name, not just "underlayment included."
  • Where self-adhered membrane goes and about how many linear feet.
  • Drip edge, starter strips, and cap nails or cap staples.
  • A per-sheet price for replacing bad decking, so surprises don't turn into change orders.

What's the best choice for the most common situation?

For a typical re-roof of an asphalt shingle roof in a mixed climate, we'd pick synthetic underlayment over the full deck plus self-adhered strips at the eaves, valleys, penetrations, and any low-slope sections. It's the best balance of protection and cost.

Synthetic costs a bit more than felt but survives rain delays, takes foot traffic, and lies flat. Targeted self-adhered membrane puts the expensive waterproofing only where leaks start. You get most of the benefit of a fully sealed roof for a fraction of the price.

Felt still has a place. On a simple, steep roof in a dry climate with a fast crew and a tight budget, 30 lb felt is acceptable if code and your shingle maker allow it. Skip 15 lb felt for a re-roof unless a contractor can show you why it suits your situation.

If you're weighing an overlay instead of a tear-off, know that it changes the underlayment question entirely. New underlayment only goes on a bare deck, so an overlay leaves the old layers, and whatever is beneath them, in place.

Next step: call your building department about permit, ice barrier, and low-slope requirements, then request three written quotes that name the underlayment product and show where the self-adhered strips go.

Questions people ask

Is synthetic underlayment worth the extra cost over felt?

For most re-roofs, yes. It typically adds a few hundred dollars on an average roof and buys better tear resistance and a flatter surface for the shingles. If the roof might sit open during unpredictable weather, the extra cost is easy to justify.

How long can underlayment stay exposed before shingles go on?

It depends on the product. Felt generally has a window of days to a few weeks, while many synthetics are rated for a month or longer. The roll label gives the exact limit, and going past it can damage the sheet or affect a warranty.

Can I install new underlayment over old shingles?

No. Underlayment goes directly on a clean, dry roof deck, so it only applies when you tear off the old roofing. With an overlay, the old shingles and the original underlayment beneath them stay in place.

Does underlayment affect my shingle warranty?

It can. Shingle manufacturers publish installation instructions, and some warranties, especially extended or system warranties, require specific underlayment or ice barrier details. Ask your roofer to confirm the requirements in writing before work starts.

Can underlayment replace a drip edge or flashing?

No. Drip edge, valley treatment, and flashing around walls and chimneys are separate components that direct water off the roof. Underlayment is a backup layer beneath them, not a substitute.

Sources and further reading

Elsewhere in Remodeling