Fix and Furrow
Advertise

Part of our Roofing and Exterior guide

Chimney Flashing Mistakes After a Roof Replacement

Reused metal, a missing saddle, and backward step flashing let a new roof leak at the chimney. Here's how to catch each one before you pay.

Save to Pinterest

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never changes what we recommend. Learn more

Metal step flashing and counterflashing along a brick chimney on a new asphalt shingle roof
Photo: Martin Martz on Unsplash

The short answer

Chimney leaks after a roof replacement usually come from five errors: reused counterflashing, no saddle on a wide chimney, step flashing installed out of order, caulk standing in for overlapping metal, and unchecked masonry. Get new flashing and any saddle in the written scope. Redoing chimney flashing typically runs about $300 to $1,500.

Typical cost
$300 to $1,500 to redo chimney flashing; $400 to $1,200 more to add a saddle
Time needed
Half a day to one full day of roofer time
Skill level
Hire a pro

Key points

  • Insist on new counterflashing, set into a mortar joint or fastened with a termination bar, rather than the old metal bent back into place.
  • A chimney wider than 30 inches, measured parallel to the ridge, generally needs a cricket (saddle) on the upslope side; confirm the rule with your local building department.
  • Step flashing must be individual pieces woven in with each shingle course, never one long strip or a late add-on.
  • Caulk and roofing cement are backups for overlapping metal, not substitutes for it.
  • Hold final payment until you've seen photos of the finished flashing and checked the attic after a heavy rain.
In this guide
  1. Why does chimney flashing leak so often on a new roof?
  2. Mistake 1: Reusing old counterflashing
  3. Mistake 2: Skipping a cricket or saddle on a wide chimney
  4. Mistake 3: Installing step flashing out of order
  5. Mistake 4: Sealing everything with caulk instead of mechanical flashing
  6. Mistake 5: Leaving the chimney crown and masonry joints unchecked
  7. What does a leak from bad flashing cost, and how do you spot it early?
  8. What should you check before paying for the chimney flashing?

Ask your roofer one thing before the tear-off starts: what happens to the old chimney flashing? If the answer is that it'll be reused, or that the gaps will be sealed, you've probably found the source of a leak that shows up months after the crew leaves. The chimney is slow, fiddly work that disappears under shingles, which is exactly why shortcuts happen there.

Why does chimney flashing leak so often on a new roof?

Chimney flashing leaks on new roofs because the joint between masonry and wood framing has to shed water and tolerate movement, and it's the first place a rushed crew cuts corners. A proper setup has four parts: an apron at the downslope face, step flashing along the sides, a back pan or chimney saddle on the upslope side, and counterflashing that laps over the top of the rest. Water should run down and over each overlap, never behind it.

Every mistake below breaks one of those overlaps. The National Roofing Contractors Association publishes flashing details for these assemblies, and your local code, usually based on the International Residential Code from the International Code Council, sets the minimums. Both are fair things to cite when you question a bid. Most towns also require a permit for a roof replacement, so ask whether the inspection covers the chimney.

Mistake 1: Reusing old counterflashing

Reusing old counterflashing is a mistake because the metal is often bent, corroded, or held in with failed caulk, and it rarely lines up with the height of the new shingles. Crews do it because removing it means grinding out mortar joints, which is dusty and slow.

The result is water slipping behind the top edge of the step flashing and soaking the wall cavity or attic framing for months before a stain appears. Ask for new metal in galvanized steel, copper, or pre-finished aluminum. Bare aluminum can corrode against fresh mortar. It should be set into a cut mortar joint roughly 3/4 inch deep, or fastened with a termination bar and sealant where cutting isn't practical. Either way, it should lap well over the step flashing, commonly 3 to 4 inches.

Grinding mortar throws off silica dust, so this is work for a crew with dust control and respirators. If your house predates 1978, ask whether the contractor follows EPA lead-safe renovation practices where painted surfaces are disturbed.

Mistake 2: Skipping a cricket or saddle on a wide chimney

A chimney wider than 30 inches, measured parallel to the ridge, generally needs a cricket, also called a chimney saddle, on its upslope side, and skipping it lets water and debris pile up behind the masonry. Code adoption varies by town, so confirm the rule locally.

Crews skip it because framing and metal-covering a saddle adds hours and materials to a job that was priced tight. Without one, the back of the chimney becomes a dam. Leaves, ice, and meltwater sit against the joint, and any small flaw turns into a leak. Put the saddle in the written scope, flashed in metal and tied into the underlayment. Narrower chimneys can often get by with a simple back pan.

Mistake 3: Installing step flashing out of order

Step flashing has to be woven in with each shingle course from the bottom up, one piece per course, because installing it late or as one long strip sends water under the metal. Some crews set shingles first and tuck metal in afterward, or substitute continuous L-flashing because it's quicker.

Here is the correct order on an asphalt shingle roof:

  1. Apply ice and water shield or underlayment up the chimney sides by several inches.
  2. Set the apron flashing at the downslope face, over the shingles below it.
  3. Lay each step flashing piece over its shingle course, with the next shingle covering it and the piece overlapping the one below by at least 2 inches.
  4. Install the back pan or saddle on the upslope side.
  5. Finish with counterflashing lapped over everything.

Nails go through the horizontal leg into the deck, never through the vertical face. A reverse-lapped piece leaks quietly inside the wall, and you won't see the damage until drywall stains.

Mistake 4: Sealing everything with caulk instead of mechanical flashing

Caulk and roofing cement are backups for gaps, not replacements for overlapping metal, and they tend to crack as the chimney and roof expand and contract through the seasons. A bead of sealant at the top of the counterflashing is normal. A thick black smear of roofing cement along the chimney sides is a warning sign.

A tube of sealant makes a job look finished in five minutes. The leak arrives after a hard freeze or a few summers of sun, and by then the sealant is hiding the real problem. Ask the crew to show you where each joint sheds water by overlap alone, with sealant added as insurance.

Mistake 5: Leaving the chimney crown and masonry joints unchecked

Leaving the crown and joints unchecked is a mistake because a cracked chimney crown, open mortar joints, or porous brick can leak into the house and look exactly like a flashing failure. Roofers rarely repair masonry, so the problem gets skipped and the new flashing gets blamed.

Ask the roofing contractor to inspect the crown and joints during the job and note problems in writing. Repointing and crown repair usually go to a mason, and scheduling that while the roof is open saves a separate access setup.

What does a leak from bad flashing cost, and how do you spot it early?

A flashing leak typically costs a few hundred dollars to fix if caught early and several thousand if water reaches framing or insulation. The ranges below are typical U.S. figures and vary with region, roof pitch, and access.

ItemTypical rangeWhat drives it
Redo chimney flashing$300 to $1,500Chimney size, metal type, masonry cutting
Add a saddle$400 to $1,200Chimney width, roof pitch
Ceiling drywall repair and paint$300 to $1,200Size of stain, texture matching
Replace rotted decking or rafters$500 to $3,000+How long it leaked, access
Mold remediation$1,000 to $5,000+Area affected, testing

Early signs include a brown ring on the ceiling near the chimney, damp insulation, a musty attic, or peeling paint on the chimney wall. Check the attic with a flashlight within a day of the first heavy rain.

What should you check before paying for the chimney flashing?

Before the final payment, confirm in writing and in photos that the flashing was replaced, lapped correctly, and checked in the attic. The FTC's consumer advice on home improvement contracts is a sensible reference for payment terms.

  • The contract names new flashing at the chimney, including counterflashing, not just "flashing as needed."
  • You have dated photos of the step flashing before shingles covered it.
  • Counterflashing is set in a mortar joint or on a termination bar, not simply caulked to the brick.
  • A chimney saddle is installed if the chimney is wider than 30 inches.
  • The roofer has noted the condition of the crown and mortar joints.
  • The attic is dry around the chimney after a heavy rain.
  • The workmanship warranty is in writing, since shingle manufacturer warranties typically cover materials, not installation.

Next step: call your roofer today, before the job starts if you can, and ask for a photo of the chimney flashing at each stage.

Questions people ask

Can chimney flashing be replaced without replacing the whole roof?

Yes. A roofer can remove the shingles around the chimney, install new flashing, and re-shingle that area. It makes the most sense when the rest of the roof is sound, and the new shingles beside the chimney will need careful matching.

Can I fix a chimney leak with roofing cement?

Roofing cement can slow a small leak for a short time, but it's a stopgap rather than a repair. If the flashing is corroded or lapped wrong, the cement hides the failure while water keeps getting in.

Is copper chimney flashing worth the extra cost?

Copper is durable and weathers well, but it costs noticeably more than galvanized steel or pre-finished aluminum. It makes the most sense on a long-term home or a roof with premium materials. Correctly installed galvanized steel is a reasonable choice for most asphalt roofs.

How long does chimney flashing last?

Lifespan depends on the metal, climate, and installation quality. Good flashing can outlast a shingle roof, but sealant at the joints may need attention sooner. Have it looked at whenever the roof or chimney is serviced.

Will my shingle warranty cover a chimney leak?

Usually not. Manufacturer warranties generally cover shingle defects, not workmanship at penetrations. Ask your roofer for a written workmanship warranty that explicitly covers flashing.

Sources and further reading

Elsewhere in Remodeling