Heat Pump vs Gas Pool Heater: Running Cost and Best Fit
A worked example for a 20,000-gallon pool shows what each heater costs per 10°F and where gas still wins.
Save to PinterestWe may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never changes what we recommend. Learn more
The short answer
A heat pump is usually cheaper to run, often about half the cost of gas per degree gained at typical U.S. rates, because it moves heat instead of burning fuel. Gas wins on speed and cold air, and can match a heat pump where electricity is expensive and gas is cheap. Buy a heat pump for steady, longer seasons; buy gas for on-demand heat.
- Typical cost
- $3,000 to $7,000 installed for a heat pump; $2,000 to $4,500 for gas with an existing line
- Time needed
- One to two days to install, plus electrician or gas fitter scheduling
- Skill level
- Hire a pro
Key points
- At typical U.S. rates, a heat pump costs roughly $22 to $30 to add 10°F to a 20,000-gallon pool, versus about $40 to $50 for natural gas and $80 to $100 for propane.
- A gas heater can add 10°F or more in a day, while a heat pump in 55°F air may net only a few degrees per day.
- Most heat pumps lose output sharply below about 45 to 50°F air, so check the spec sheet for the minimum operating temperature.
- Where electricity runs near $0.30 per kWh and natural gas is cheap, the running-cost gap can shrink to almost nothing.
- A solar pool cover cuts heating cost on either system, and it usually matters more than the brand on the cabinet.
In this guide
- How do a heat pump and a gas pool heater warm the water?
- How much more does a heat pump cost to buy and install?
- Which is cheaper to run at typical utility rates?
- How do they perform in cool and cold air?
- Do pool size, climate, and season length matter more than brand?
- What about maintenance, lifespan, and hidden costs?
- Which one should you buy for your situation?
For a typical 20,000-gallon pool at typical U.S. rates, a heat pump costs roughly half as much as gas to add each degree of warmth, but gas heats faster and keeps working when the air turns cold. That tradeoff, not the sticker price, decides most purchases. The figures below are estimates built on stated assumptions, so swap in your own gas and electric rates before you commit.
How do a heat pump and a gas pool heater warm the water?
A gas heater burns natural gas or propane to heat water passing through a heat exchanger, while a heat pump uses electricity to pull heat out of the outside air and move it into the pool.
Gas makes heat, so it doesn't care how cold the air is. A heat pump collects heat, so its output depends on air temperature and humidity. Efficiency is expressed as a coefficient of performance, or COP: a COP of 5 means five units of heat delivered for every unit of electricity used. Spec sheets quote the best case, usually around 80°F air. In 55°F October air, expect something closer to 3 or 4. Gas heaters are rated by thermal efficiency, roughly 80 to 95 percent depending on the model.
Then there's speed. A 20,000-gallon pool holds about 167,000 pounds of water, and each degree Fahrenheit takes about 167,000 BTU. A 400,000 BTU gas heater at about 83 percent efficiency delivers roughly 330,000 BTU per hour, close to 2°F per hour before the pool's own heat loss is subtracted. A typical heat pump puts out around 100,000 BTU per hour in warm air and less in cool air. That's at most about 0.6°F per hour, and it has to run most of the day.
| Factor | Heat pump | Gas heater |
|---|---|---|
| Installed cost | $3,000 to $7,000 | $2,000 to $4,500 with a gas line in place |
| Cost to add 10°F (20,000 gal) | About $22 to $30 at $0.17/kWh | About $40 to $50 natural gas; $80 to $100 propane |
| Heating speed | Slow; a few degrees net per day in 55°F air | Fast; 10°F or more in a day |
| Low air temperature | Output drops below about 45 to 50°F | Works at any air temperature |
| Typical lifespan | Often 10 to 15 years | Often 8 to 12 years |
| Best fit | Regular swimming, long seasons | Occasional use, cold climates, spa spillover |
How much more does a heat pump cost to buy and install?
A heat pump typically runs $3,000 to $7,000 installed, while a gas pool heater runs $2,000 to $4,500 when a gas line is already near the equipment pad.
Size and brand move the price, but the site matters more. A new natural gas line can add $500 to $2,500 or more depending on trench length and your utility. A propane pool heater needs a tank, which adds cost and delivery logistics. A heat pump needs a dedicated 240-volt circuit, usually 30 to 60 amps depending on the model, and if your panel has no room an electrician may add $400 to $1,500 or more for the circuit or a panel upgrade.
Which is cheaper to run at typical utility rates?
A heat pump is cheaper to run in most of the country, usually costing about half as much as natural gas per degree gained and roughly a third as much as propane.
The assumptions: a 20,000-gallon pool, a 25 percent allowance for heat lost to evaporation and wind while heating, a gas heater at about 83 percent efficiency, and a heat pump averaging a COP of 4 in shoulder-season air. Natural gas is figured at $1.80 per therm and electricity at $0.17 per kWh. These are typical figures, not quotes, and your bills will differ.
| Scenario | Gas, per 10°F | Heat pump, per 10°F |
|---|---|---|
| Natural gas $1.80/therm, electric $0.17/kWh | $40 to $50 | $22 to $30 |
| Propane near $3.20/gal, electric $0.17/kWh | $80 to $100 | $22 to $30 |
| Natural gas $1.80/therm, electric $0.30/kWh | $40 to $50 | $40 to $52 |
Stretch that over a season. Say you hold 82°F for six weeks of September and October, and the pool loses about 4°F a day uncovered or about 2°F a day under a cover. Those losses are assumptions, and wind and humidity can move them a lot. On that basis a heat pump pool heater lands around $225 to $450 for the six weeks, natural gas around $380 to $760, and propane roughly double the natural gas figure.
The third table row is the catch. In high-rate areas, a heat pump can lose most of its advantage.
How do they perform in cool and cold air?
Heat pump output falls as air cools, and most units slow sharply or stop below roughly 45 to 50°F, while a gas heater has no air-temperature floor.
In 55°F air a heat pump delivers noticeably less than its rated output at a lower COP. That still beats gas on cost but adds heat slowly, so a pool that drops 5°F on a cold night may take most of the next day to recover. Below the unit's minimum operating air temperature, it may shut off or spend much of its time in defrost cycles. Some cold-climate models run lower. The manufacturer's spec sheet lists the minimum, so read it before you buy a heat pump pool heater for a northern yard.
Gas shines on a cold, clear weekend when you want 82°F by Saturday afternoon. It burns more fuel doing it, but it gets there.
Do pool size, climate, and season length matter more than brand?
Yes, surface area, local air temperature, wind exposure, and how many weeks you want to swim shape running cost far more than the brand on the cabinet.
Heat loss tracks surface area more than volume, so a wide, shallow, windy pool is costly to heat on any system. Sizing is where mistakes happen. An undersized heat pump runs around the clock and never catches up. Ask installers to size the unit from your pool's surface area, your October air temperatures, and your target water temperature, and be wary of anyone who sizes by gallons alone.
Season length is the other lever. If you only want to push the season out two or three weeks, the lower running cost of a heat pump may take years to repay its higher purchase price. If you swim from April to November, the savings stack up much faster.
What about maintenance, lifespan, and hidden costs?
Both heaters need little routine maintenance, but a heat pump typically lasts a few years longer, and each has its own hidden costs.
A heat pump needs clear airflow around the evaporator coil, a gentle cleaning now and then, and balanced water. Many units use a titanium heat exchanger that resists chlorine, but a failed compressor is an expensive repair. Gas heaters suffer when pH and alkalinity drift: low pH corrodes the heat exchanger, and high pH scales it. Igniters, sensors, and venting parts also wear out over time.
A heat pump needs water flowing through it for many hours a day, so a single-speed pump running longer adds to your electric bill, and a variable-speed pump softens that. Gas needs a code-compliant location with proper venting and clearances. And a new natural gas line or electrical upgrade can change the math entirely.
Which one should you buy for your situation?
For most homeowners who swim regularly across a long season, we'd pick a heat pump, and we'd pick gas for occasional use, cold climates, or heating a spa quickly.
- Hot and mild climates (Gulf Coast, Florida, Southern California, Arizona, much of Texas): heat pump. Air stays warm enough for good output, and the savings are steady.
- Middle latitudes (Carolinas, Mid-Atlantic, Midwest, Pacific Northwest valleys): heat pump with a cover if you swim most weekends. Add gas only if you want fast heat on short notice after a cold night.
- Cold climates with freezing October nights: gas, or a cold-climate heat pump if you accept slower recovery.
- Weekend-only or occasional swimmers: gas. You pay only for the hours you heat, and there's no need to run a pump all day.
- Propane-only properties: a heat pump, unless you rarely swim. Propane costs the most per degree.
- High electric rates and cheap natural gas: run the numbers. The gap may be small enough that upfront cost decides it.
Your next step: pull last year's utility bills to find your cost per therm and per kWh, then get two written quotes that include sizing, the minimum operating air temperature, and any panel or gas-line work.
Questions people ask
Can a heat pump heat a pool in winter?
In mild climates, yes, though slowly. Where air regularly drops below 45 to 50°F, most heat pumps lose enough output that you'll rarely reach comfortable swimming temperatures. Cold-climate models extend that range but still can't match gas in a freeze.
Does a heat pump have to run all day?
Usually it does, because it adds heat slowly. It works best running during the warmest daytime hours and holding the temperature rather than recovering from a big drop. Pair it with a pool cover so it isn't fighting overnight losses.
Should I turn the heater off between swims?
With gas, turning it down or off when you're away saves fuel, since it can reheat in hours. With a heat pump, large swings undercut its slow-and-steady strength, so a modest setback is usually more economical than shutting it off for days.
Can I install both a heat pump and a gas heater?
Yes. Some owners run the heat pump for everyday upkeep and use the gas heater for fast heat on cold days or spa spillover. It costs more upfront but covers both the efficiency and speed gaps.
Is a solar pool cover worth it with either heater?
Generally yes. It slows evaporation, the largest source of heat loss, and costs far less than a heater. The savings are biggest in cool, windy weather.
Sources and further reading
- Electrical Safety Foundation International Electrical safety resources, including wiring and equipment near water
- National Fire Protection Association Fire safety codes and homeowner resources
Was this article helpful?