Fix and Furrow
Advertise

Solar vs Plug-In String Lights for Patio: Which Wins?

Plug-in sets win on reliability, solar wins on easy placement. Here is where the line falls, and when to mix the two.

Save to Pinterest

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never changes what we recommend. Learn more

Patio with string lights glowing over an outdoor dining table at dusk
Photo: Randy Fath on Unsplash

The short answer

For most patios, plug-in LED string lights are the better buy: they run at full brightness every night, in shade or winter, and typically cost about $2 to $7 a year to power. Solar string lights make sense only if the panel gets roughly six hours of direct sun and you want zero wiring. A hybrid often beats both.

Typical cost
$25 to $70 for a 24-foot solar set; $55 to $130 for a plug-in set with cord and timer, plus $150 to $400 if you add an outlet
Time needed
30 minutes to 2 hours to hang, plus a day or two to test solar placement
Skill level
Beginner

Key points

  • Plug-in LED sets give consistent brightness in any weather, and a 24-foot run typically costs about $2 to $7 a year in electricity.
  • Solar string lights depend on direct sun on the panel, so a shaded or north-facing patio can leave them dim or dark early in the evening.
  • The real cost of plug-in is the power source: an outdoor extension cord is cheap, while a new GFCI outlet from an electrician runs $150 to $400.
  • Over three years the two cost about the same, because solar sets need new batteries or a replacement set while plug-in needs a cord, a timer and a few dollars of power.
  • A hybrid layout, plug-in over the dining table and solar along the fence or railing, fits most yards best.
In this guide
  1. How Do Solar and Plug-In String Lights Actually Work?
  2. Side-by-Side: Brightness, Runtime, Cost, and Install
  3. Where Does Solar Win?
  4. Where Does Plug-In Win?
  5. What Does Each Cost Over Three Years?
  6. How Do You Test Shade, Clouds, and Winter Before You Buy?
  7. Which Should You Choose for Your Patio?

Plug-in LED string lights are the more dependable pick for most patios, and solar only wins when the panel gets real sun. The gap shows up in shade, in winter, and at dinner, when you need enough light to see your plate.

How Do Solar and Plug-In String Lights Actually Work?

Solar string lights charge a small battery through a built-in solar panel during the day and drain it after dark, while plug-in sets draw steady power from an outlet.

The panel is the part that matters. It is usually a few inches across, sits at the end of the cord, and needs direct sun on its face. Light falling on the bulbs does nothing. Most sets use small rechargeable batteries, which are replaceable in some models and sealed in others.

Plug-in sets are simpler. You hang the string, run an outdoor extension cord or reach an outdoor outlet, and add an outdoor-rated timer so the lights switch on at dusk. LED sets draw so little power that electricity is no longer the issue it was with older incandescent-style strings.

Side-by-Side: Brightness, Runtime, Cost, and Install

Plug-in sets win on brightness and runtime, solar wins on install and placement freedom, and cost depends on whether you already have a nearby outlet.

FactorSolar string lightsPlug-in LED string lights
BrightnessSoft glow, often dimmer than plug-in bulbs; check lumens on the packageBrighter, especially commercial-grade string lights with larger bulbs
RuntimeOften advertised at 6 to 10 hours after a sunny day; much less after cloud or in shadeAs long as you set the timer
Upfront cost (24 ft)About $25 to $70About $25 to $60 for the string, plus cord or outlet
Running costBattery replacementAbout $2 to $7 a year in electricity
InstallHang and aim the panelHang, then solve the power source
Shade performancePoor unless the panel sits in sunUnaffected

Solar runtimes vary by product, panel size, and latitude. The package claim is a best case, usually after a full summer day.

Where Does Solar Win?

Solar wins in sunny yards, in spots with no outlet within reach, and anywhere you don't want a cord crossing a walkway.

Think of a pergola across the lawn, a fence line, a path edge, a gazebo railing. Power in those places means trenching or a long cord. If the panel gets roughly six hours of direct sun in summer, solar string lights will usually give you a pleasant evening glow with no wiring at all.

Solar also suits renters and anyone who rearranges often. Some sets put the panel on a separate lead, which matters in a partly shaded yard: leave the bulbs under the pergola and stake the panel in the one sunny spot.

Where Does Plug-In Win?

Plug-in wins in shade, in late fall and winter, and anywhere the lights need to be bright enough to read a menu or pour a drink.

A north-facing or tree-covered patio is the classic solar failure. The panel collects a couple of hours of weak light, and the set quits early in the evening, often right when guests arrive. Short days make it worse. In northern states the sun is low and the days are short from roughly November through February, so a set that worked in July can fade fast.

Plug-in sets also give you control. A timer, a dimmer, or a smart plug lets you decide how bright and for how long. We'd pick plug-in for any space where you eat or entertain regularly.

What Does Each Cost Over Three Years?

Over three years, a plug-in setup runs about $60 to $150 with a cord and timer, while solar runs about $35 to $120 once you count battery or set replacements.

Cost item (24-ft run)SolarPlug-in
String lights$25 to $70$25 to $60
Outdoor extension cord (25 to 50 ft)None$20 to $45
Outdoor-rated timerNone$10 to $25
Batteries or replacement$10 to $50 over three yearsNone
Electricity, three yearsNone$6 to $21
Typical total$35 to $120$60 to $150

The electricity line is simple math. A 24-foot LED set drawing 10 to 25 watts for four hours a night uses roughly 15 to 37 kilowatt-hours a year. At 15 to 20 cents per kilowatt-hour, that's about $2 to $7 annually. Check the wattage on your package, since larger bulbs draw more. An older incandescent-style set pulling 100 to 150 watts would run closer to $20 to $45 a year, so buy LED.

If there's no outdoor outlet, adding a GFCI outlet through a licensed electrician typically runs $150 to $400, depending on distance, wall type, and local rates. That one line can flip the math toward solar for a remote corner.

Solar costs creep up quietly. Cheap sets often have sealed batteries, and when those fade after a few seasons you buy a new set. Replaceable cells last longer if you swap them at the first sign of dimming.

How Do You Test Shade, Clouds, and Winter Before You Buy?

Test by watching where direct sun actually lands on the spot where the panel would sit, at three times of day, before you spend anything.

  1. Check the panel location at about 10 a.m., noon, and 3 p.m. You want direct sun on most of those checks, not bright shade.
  2. Repeat the check in the season you care about. A spot that's sunny in June can be shaded in December by the house or a tree's bare branches, and the sun sits lower.
  3. Buy a set with a return window, charge it for a full sunny day, and time how long it lasts. Then see what it does after a cloudy day.
  4. If you want lights through the holidays, run the same test in your shortest-daylight month.

If your patio is covered or heavily shaded, skip the test and go plug-in. Solar can't make power it doesn't receive.

Which Should You Choose for Your Patio?

Choose plug-in if the patio is shaded or you want bright, scheduled light, solar if it gets full sun and has no power nearby, and a hybrid for most mixed yards.

  • Shaded or north-facing patio: plug-in. Solar will disappoint.
  • Sunny, open patio with no outlet: solar, with the panel in the sunniest spot.
  • Dining or entertaining area: plug-in with commercial-grade string lights and an outdoor-rated timer.
  • Fence line, railing, or garden edge: solar for accent light.
  • Year-round use in a cold climate: plug-in, since winter solar output drops.

The hybrid is our default recommendation. Put plug-in lights over the table, where you need dependable light, and use solar for the perimeter, where a dim glow is fine and cords would be a nuisance.

Lighting a single party or event?

For one night, plug-in lights are the safer bet, because they give full brightness for as long as the party runs, whatever the weather did that day. Use solar only if no outlet is within reach, and give the panel a full day of direct sun before the event. In fall, expect solar sets to run noticeably shorter.

For one event, the two cost about the same once you count an extension cord and timer. If you need 100 feet or more of commercial-grade lights once and have nowhere to store them, renting can beat buying; prices vary a lot by market, so get a couple of quotes.

Your next step: measure the run, note the nearest outlet, and spend one afternoon checking where the sun lands on your patio. That answer settles most of the decision.

Questions people ask

Are solar patio lights worth it?

They are worth it when the panel gets about six hours of direct sun and the lights are for ambient glow, not task lighting. In shade or in winter they usually underperform, and plug-in is the better value.

How long do solar string lights stay on at night?

Package claims often say 6 to 10 hours, but that assumes a full, sunny day. After overcast weather or on short winter days, many sets run only a couple of hours or not at all.

Can I use solar string lights under a covered patio?

Only if the panel can sit outside the cover in direct sun. Look for a set with a long lead between the panel and the bulbs, otherwise the battery won't charge properly.

How many string light sets can I connect together?

Follow the limit printed on the package or tag, which is usually given as a maximum number of strands or a total wattage. Exceeding it can overheat the cord or plug, which is a fire risk.

Do I need an electrician to install plug-in string lights?

Not if an outdoor GFCI outlet is within cord reach. Adding a new outdoor outlet is work for a licensed electrician, and many areas require a permit.

Can I leave outdoor string lights up all winter?

Many commercial-grade plug-in sets are made for it, but check the rating and use a GFCI outlet. Batteries in cheap solar sets can lose capacity in freezing weather, so store them if the package suggests it.

Sources and further reading

Elsewhere in Outdoor Living