Fix and Furrow
Advertise

Polycarbonate vs Greenhouse Film for Hoop House: Real Costs

Film costs a fraction up front, but frame width, snow load, and how long you'll stay put can flip the answer.

Save to Pinterest

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never changes what we recommend. Learn more

Backyard hoop house with clear plastic film stretched over steel hoops beside raised garden beds
Photo: wei on Unsplash

The short answer

For most DIY hoop houses, 6 mil polyethylene film is the better buy: about $90 to $220 to cover a 12x20 frame, replaced every 3 to 4 years. Twin wall polycarbonate runs roughly $900 to $2,000 for the same frame but lasts 10 to 15 years, insulates better, and resists snow and small hail better. Choose it only for a permanent, sturdy frame.

Typical cost
$90 to $220 for film, $900 to $2,000 for polycarbonate (12x20 frame)
Time needed
One afternoon for film, one weekend for polycarbonate
Skill level
Intermediate

Key points

  • A 12x20 hoop house costs roughly $90 to $220 to cover in 6 mil film versus $900 to $2,000 in twin wall polycarbonate.
  • Film works out to about $25 to $55 per year and polycarbonate to about $65 to $230 per year, so polycarbonate rarely wins on price alone.
  • Polycarbonate panels can't bend as tightly as film, so narrow, tall hoops and light PVC frames are film-only.
  • Double-layer film with a small blower comes close to polycarbonate's insulation for far less money.
  • Renters and seedling-only growers should buy film; permanent cold-climate growers with strong steel frames can consider polycarbonate.
In this guide
  1. How do polycarbonate and greenhouse film differ in light, heat, and durability?
  2. Side-by-side comparison: cost, lifespan, light, and install
  3. Where does polycarbonate win?
  4. Where does greenhouse film win?
  5. What's the real cost per season, including replacements?
  6. What frame spacing and snow load can each covering handle?
  7. Which cover fits your situation?

For a typical 12x20 foot hoop house, 6 mil greenhouse film costs roughly $90 to $220 per cover, while twin wall polycarbonate for the same frame runs about $900 to $2,000. That gap is most of the decision. The rest turns on how wide and stiff your hoops are, how much snow and hail you get, and whether you'll still be growing in that yard a dozen years from now.

Prices here are typical U.S. ranges for a frame needing roughly 450 to 500 square feet of covering, counting end walls, overlap, and the edge you bury or clamp. Supplier, shipping (rolls and panels are bulky), and panel thickness will move your numbers.

How do polycarbonate and greenhouse film differ in light, heat, and durability?

Film is a thin, flexible sheet that stretches over any curve, while polycarbonate is a rigid panel with air channels that holds its shape, insulates better, and lasts several times longer. Light slightly favors film: clear polyethylene greenhouse film passes roughly 85 to 90 percent of sunlight, and twin wall polycarbonate passes roughly 75 to 83 percent depending on thickness and tint. Most crops do fine with that difference, and the diffused light from panels can ease leaf scorch on tender plants.

Heat is where polycarbonate pulls ahead. Single-layer film insulates at about R-1, double-layer film with air blown between the sheets is roughly R-1.5, and 6 to 8 mm twin wall polycarbonate lands near R-1.5 to R-2. Those figures are approximate, and manufacturers publish their own. The fair comparison is against double-layer film, which gets close for a fraction of the price but needs an inflation blower running.

Durability comes down to UV and wear. A film sold as 4-year is UV-stabilized for about four growing seasons, so check the UV rating on the package first. Cheap clear sheeting can fall apart in a single summer. Film also wears where it touches hot metal hoops and where wind makes it flap. Polycarbonate usually carries its UV-protective layer on one face only. That face must point at the sun, and a panel installed backward can degrade much faster.

Side-by-side comparison: cost, lifespan, light, and install

Film wins on price, flexibility, and ease of install; polycarbonate wins on lifespan, insulation, and storm resistance.

FactorPolyethylene film (6 mil)Twin wall polycarbonate (6 to 8 mm)
Cover cost, 12x20 frame$90 to $220$900 to $2,000
Typical lifespan3 to 4 years10 to 15 years
Light transmissionAbout 85 to 90%About 75 to 83%
Insulation (approx.)R-1 single, R-1.5 doubleR-1.5 to R-2
Hail and snowCan tear; frame carries the loadRigid; large hail can still crack it
Hoop requirementsAny bend, light frame is fineGentle arc, sturdy frame
InstallOne or two people, one afternoonTwo people, a weekend, drilling and sealing
Re-coveringEvery 3 to 4 years, about half a dayRarely; single panels swap out

Where does polycarbonate win?

Polycarbonate wins on lifespan, storm resistance, and winter heat retention, which is why it suits permanent frames in cold climates. If you grow through January in a cold USDA zone (look yours up on the USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map), the built-in air gap cuts heating cost without a blower or a second layer.

It also ends recurring re-covering. Rigid polycarbonate panels don't flap, don't sag under wet snow the way loose film can, and handle small hail better than film. They're quieter in wind, too, which neighbors and light sleepers notice.

Where does greenhouse film win?

Greenhouse film wins on upfront cost, on fitting any frame shape, and on how cheaply you can fix a mistake. A bad cut in a roll of film hurts less than a cracked polycarbonate panel, and film wraps over 1/2-inch PVC hoops that can't support rigid panels.

It's also the flexible choice if your plans change. You can pull film off in summer for open-air growing, roll the sides for ventilation, or take it down entirely if you move. For renters, that portability is the whole argument.

Installation is straightforward on a warm, calm day. Hold the film in place with lock channel and wiggle wire instead of staples or tape, since punched holes tear. Pad the hoops where the film touches them. Pull it snug but not drum-tight, because film contracts in cold and slackens in heat. A second person makes this far easier.

If you add an inflation blower for double-layer film, plug it into a GFCI-protected outdoor outlet. Running a new circuit to the greenhouse is a job for a licensed electrician.

What's the real cost per season, including replacements?

Over a 10 to 15 year span, film works out to roughly $25 to $55 per year and polycarbonate to roughly $65 to $230 per year, so film is cheaper per season even after repeated re-covering.

OptionFirst-year outlayAssumed lifeCost per year
Single-layer film$140 to $370 (cover plus hardware)4 years per cover$25 to $55 on later covers
Double-layer film with blower$290 to $7904 years per cover$45 to $110 on later covers
Twin wall polycarbonate$1,000 to $2,300 (panels, framing, sealing)10 to 15 years$65 to $230

Treat these as planning figures. The film hardware (lock channel, wiggle wire, an inflation blower) is a one-time cost, which is why later covers cost less than the first. Polycarbonate lands at the high end if you add stronger hoops to carry it.

The takeaway is blunt: polycarbonate doesn't pay back on cover cost alone. It pays back through lower heating bills, fewer storm losses, and no re-covering work, and only you know what those are worth. If a hailstorm shreds a film cover in year two, the math tightens. If you only grow April to October in a mild climate, it never will.

What frame spacing and snow load can each covering handle?

Film tolerates almost any frame, while polycarbonate needs supports every 2 to 4 feet and a bend gentle enough that the panel doesn't kink or crack. Manufacturers often quote a cold-bend limit of roughly 100 to 175 times the panel thickness, which puts a 6 mm panel near a 2 to 3.5 foot minimum radius. Check the specific manufacturer's number before you buy.

Frame factorFilmPolycarbonate
Hoop spacingCommonly 4 ft on center; up to 6 ft with ridge purlins in mild climatesUsually 2 to 4 ft, per panel span tables
Hoop material1/2-inch PVC for light use; galvanized steel tubing for snowSteel; PVC isn't stiff enough
Bow shapeNarrow or wide, any riseWide, gentle arc or gothic with a flat section
Snow behaviorSheds snow if kept warm; unheated, the frame takes the weightRigid; steep pitch helps it shed

Bow width matters too. A hoop wider than about 14 feet with a low rise tends to flatten at the top and hold snow, whichever covering you choose. Steeper arches shed better. If you already built a narrow, tall PVC frame, polycarbonate is off the table without rebuilding.

Which cover fits your situation?

For the most common situation, a backyard grower with a hoop frame under about 14 feet wide, we'd pick 6 mil, 4-year UV polyethylene film, in a double layer if you plan to grow through winter. It's the cheapest way to find out how much you'll actually use the structure.

  • Renters: Single-layer film. It comes down with the frame, and you won't sink money into rigid panels you can't take with you.
  • Cold climates, winter growing: Double-layer film with an inflation blower if the budget is tight; twin wall polycarbonate if the frame is steel, well anchored, and permanent. The hybrid with polycarbonate end walls is a strong middle path.
  • Seedlings only: Single-layer film. You need frost protection from March to May, not insulation, and a smaller project may be better served by a cold frame built from an old window.
  • Long-term growers with a permanent site: Polycarbonate, but only after you've confirmed the frame can carry it and your bend radius works.

Your next step is to measure your hoop's arc length and width, then call your county about snow load before you price anything. Your state's Cooperative Extension office, listed at extension.org, is a good place to ask about local hoop house practice.

Questions people ask

Can I put polycarbonate panels on PVC hoops?

Generally no. PVC bows flex under the weight and wind load of rigid panels, and the arc is usually too tight for them to bend without cracking. Polycarbonate needs steel hoops or a purpose-built frame.

How thick should greenhouse film be?

6 mil is the standard for backyard hoop houses and balances strength, clarity, and price. Thinner plastic tears faster in wind, and thicker film is harder to pull tight by hand.

Is clear painter's plastic a good cheap cover?

It works for a short trial, but it lacks UV stabilization and often breaks down within a season or less of full sun. Proper greenhouse film costs little more and lasts years.

How can I make greenhouse film last longer?

Pad every spot where it touches a hoop, secure it with lock channel instead of staples, and keep it taut so it doesn't flap. If you aren't growing through winter, take it down or re-tighten it ahead of high-wind forecasts, and store spare film out of the sun.

Which side of twin wall polycarbonate faces the sun?

The side with the UV-protective coating faces out, toward the sun. Most panels ship with a label or printed film marking that face, so leave it on until the panel is mounted and check the manufacturer's instructions.

Sources and further reading

Elsewhere in Gardening