Fix and Furrow
Advertise

Part of our Home Repair Troubleshooting guide

Holes in Kale Leaves in Fall: Match the Damage to the Pest

Round pinholes, ragged chunks with green droppings, and slime-trailed holes each point to a different pest and a different fix.

Save to Pinterest

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never changes what we recommend. Learn more

Kale leaf with ragged holes and a green caterpillar on the underside in a fall garden
Photo: Martin Martz on Unsplash

The short answer

Ragged, chunky holes with dark green droppings usually mean cabbage loopers or imported cabbageworms, the most common fall culprits. Tiny round pinholes on young leaves mean flea beetles. Irregular holes with silver slime trails mean slugs or snails. Check leaf undersides with a flashlight, then match the fix to the pest.

Typical cost
$10 to $60 for Bt spray, slug bait, or row cover
Time needed
Ten minutes by day, one evening check for slugs, then a few weeks of follow-up
Skill level
Beginner

Key points

  • Hole shape and location narrow the pest down faster than hunting for bugs at random.
  • Cabbage loopers and imported cabbageworms stay active into fall, and cool nights slow how fast Bt works, so give a spray several days before judging it.
  • Flea beetles mostly punish seedlings, while established kale usually shrugs off their pinholes.
  • Slug damage shows up as irregular holes plus silver trails, and it needs bait or trapping instead of caterpillar sprays.
  • Floating row cover only helps if you check for pests first and seal the edges.
In this guide
  1. How Do You Tell What Is Eating Kale From the Holes?
  2. Are Cabbage Loopers and Imported Cabbageworms the Most Common Cause?
  3. Are Flea Beetles Making Tiny Round Holes in Kale?
  4. How Do You Spot Slug Damage on Brassica Leaves?
  5. How Can You Check for Each Cause?
  6. What Fixes Work in Cool Fall Weather?
  7. Do Row Covers Protect the Rest of the Season?
  8. When Should You Call an Extension Office or Pro?

Grab a flashlight and look at the underside of the most chewed leaf. Velvety green caterpillars or dark green pellets answer the question for most fall kale. If you find neither, the shape of the holes tells you where to look next.

How Do You Tell What Is Eating Kale From the Holes?

The shape, size, and position of the holes identify the pest more reliably than hunting for bugs at random, because many of these feeders hide by day. The table gives the quick match.

What you seeLikely causeWhere it hitsQuick confirm
Large ragged chunks, dark green droppingsCabbage loopers, imported cabbagewormsAny leaf, often the middle and undersideGreen caterpillars on leaf undersides
Many tiny round holes, smaller than a pencil eraserFlea beetlesYoung leaves and seedlingsSmall dark beetles that jump when you brush the plant
Irregular holes, ragged edges, silver trailsSlugs and snailsLower leaves, leaves touching soilShiny trails in the morning; slugs after dark

Damage can overlap. A plant with three kinds of holes may have three kinds of pests, so treat the worst problem first.

Are Cabbage Loopers and Imported Cabbageworms the Most Common Cause?

Yes, in most U.S. gardens the large ragged holes in fall kale come from cabbage loopers and imported cabbageworms. The adults are moths (loopers) and white butterflies (cabbageworms), and they keep laying eggs while days stay mild. Timing varies by region, so check your zone on the USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map and look up your local first-frost date.

Imported cabbageworms are velvety green and slow-moving. Loopers are paler, with thin white stripes, and they arch their backs as they crawl. Both leave dark green droppings, called frass, on the leaf surface and in the crinkles near the center of the plant.

Here's the fall catch. Bt spray (Bacillus thuringiensis kurstaki) only works after a caterpillar eats treated leaf tissue. Cool nights slow feeding, so results can take longer than the label's usual timeline. Gardeners often decide the spray failed and give up. It usually didn't fail. It's just slow.

Are Flea Beetles Making Tiny Round Holes in Kale?

Yes, many tiny round holes, often called shothole damage, are the signature of flea beetles. The beetles are roughly 1/16 to 1/8 inch long, usually black or bronze, and they hop like fleas when disturbed.

The damage matters most on seedlings and fresh transplants, where a heavy attack can stunt or kill the plant. On established kale it's mostly cosmetic. If you planted a fall crop in August or September and it's still small, protect it. If the plants are already a foot across, you can usually live with the holes.

How Do You Spot Slug Damage on Brassica Leaves?

Slug damage on brassica leaves looks like irregular holes in the lower leaves, with dried silver slime trails on the leaf or the soil nearby. Slugs and snails feed at night and in cool, damp weather, which describes a lot of October.

Unlike caterpillar holes, slug holes come without chunky green droppings. The damage tends to start at the bottom of the plant and work up.

How Can You Check for Each Cause?

Three quick checks separate the suspects: flip leaves for caterpillars by day, tap young leaves over paper for flea beetles, and go out after dark for slugs.

  1. Caterpillar check: Flip five or six leaves and look along the midribs and in the center crown for green larvae, tiny yellow eggs, or dark green pellets.
  2. Flea beetle check: Hold a sheet of white paper under a young leaf and tap the plant. Tiny dark specks that jump are flea beetles.
  3. Slug check: Go out an hour after dark with a flashlight and look at the lower leaves and the soil surface. Lift a board or flowerpot you left on the bed the night before.

If you find nothing, check again in two nights. New damage means something is still feeding. Old damage just stays put.

What Fixes Work in Cool Fall Weather?

In cool weather, hand-picking plus Bt spray works for caterpillars, bait or traps work for slugs, and a physical barrier works for flea beetles. We'd pick hand-picking first for a small bed, because it works at any temperature and costs nothing. Drop the caterpillars into a jar of soapy water.

For larger plantings, use Bt spray on a mild day while caterpillars are feeding. Cover the leaf undersides and the center of the plant, and reapply on the schedule printed on the label. Expect slower results when nights are cold. For heavy infestations, a product with spinosad is another option sold for organic gardening, but it's toxic to bees when wet, so apply it in the evening and follow the label closely.

For slugs, use iron phosphate bait, a slug bait labeled for use around vegetables, or set boards and trap them each morning. Pull mulch and fallen leaves away from the plant stems. For flea beetles, a physical barrier (see the next section) does the most, and even watering helps seedlings outgrow the damage.

Do Row Covers Protect the Rest of the Season?

Yes, a floating row cover protects kale well if you check for pests first and seal every edge. Lightweight fabric or insect netting over hoops keeps out egg-laying moths, butterflies, and flea beetles. Bury the edges in soil or pin them tight, because one gap lets the moths in.

Timing matters. Cover the bed before eggs get laid, not after. If caterpillars are already inside, the cover just gives them a protected place to eat. Slugs can hide under covers too, so bait the bed first if you've seen trails.

You can harvest outer leaves all fall, and kale tastes sweeter after light frosts. Pull yellowed or heavily chewed leaves and compost them so eggs and pupae don't overwinter in the bed. Our raised bed fall checklist covers the rest of the cleanup by climate.

When Should You Call an Extension Office or Pro?

Call your local Cooperative Extension office when the damage doesn't match any of the three patterns, or when plants are wilting, stunting, or dying instead of just getting holes. A wilting plant with a damaged root system points to something else, such as root maggots or disease. You can find your county office through Cooperative Extension.

Entire plants stripped overnight, or clean angled cuts on stems and leaf edges, usually point to rabbits or deer rather than insects. A fence solves that, and our guide to deer fence cost for a vegetable garden covers the price range.

Your next step is tonight. Go out after dark with a flashlight and check the lower leaves, then flip five leaves in the morning. Whatever you find decides which fix you buy.

Questions people ask

Are kale leaves with holes safe to eat?

Yes, in most cases. Holes themselves are harmless, and you can wash off caterpillars and frass. Trim away any slimy or rotting areas, and follow the waiting period on the label if you've sprayed.

Will frost kill the caterpillars on my kale?

A hard freeze usually kills or stops active caterpillars and ends butterfly and moth activity for the year. Light frosts often just slow them down. Kale tolerates cold better than the pests do, so keep checking until temperatures stay low.

Is Bt safe around bees and pets?

Bt kurstaki targets moth and butterfly larvae and is generally considered low risk to bees, people, and pets when used as labeled. It will also kill other caterpillars it touches, including monarchs on nearby plants, so spray only the kale. Check the product label for details.

Do holes in kale mean the plant has a disease?

Usually not. Holes point to chewing pests, while disease tends to show up as spots, yellowing, or wilting. If you see those instead of holes, take a leaf to your local Cooperative Extension office.

Should I pull kale that is heavily chewed?

Not necessarily. Established kale often regrows from the center if the growing point is intact. Pull the plant only if it's stunted, wilting, or the growing center is destroyed.

Sources and further reading

Elsewhere in Gardening